In the media
Labor’s appalling migration bill is a ‘race to the bottom’ with Peter Dutton
Labor’s appalling migration bill is a ‘race to the bottom’ with Peter Dutton
The government’s plan to ban mobile phones and introduce sniffer dogs in immigration facilities will create Australian-made Guantanamo-esque detention camps.
This Labor re-run of Peter Dutton’s 2020 proposal to ban immigration detainees from accessing mobile phones is an appalling race to the bottom.
In 2020 Labor’s Andrew Giles said there was, “no justification for blanket prohibitions”.
While Josh Burns, the current Labor Chair of the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights, said Peter Dutton’s 2020 bill was “not about a proportionate response from government but about cruelty and politics”.
What has changed, other than Labor running scared of Peter Dutton?
While Labor has been inching closer to the Coalition on immigration policy, they are no longer trying to hide the fact that their immigration policies are a ‘cut and paste’ of Peter Dutton’s.
Mobile phones are a lifeline for people in immigration detention helping them to communicate with family, friends and the outside world. This is an attempt by Labor to silence a Peter Dutton scare campaign on immigration while silencing any criticism from detainees – preventing them from speaking to journalists, or advocates.
Tony Burke’s assertion that Labor is simply implementing a recommendation of the Human Rights Commission is disingenuous. Labor is failing to prioritise the 29 other recommendations that would make Australia’s immigration detention regime more humane. For example, where is the urgency to invest in education and vocational training programs, increase access to support services or drug and alcohol rehab programs?
The way the draft legislation stands, the government of the day could also decide to confiscate reading glasses from detainees if the Minister deemed them a prohibited item. It’s scary to think what restrictions a Dutton-Government could implement under these reforms.
While the government argues Border Force need these powers, Police already have the power to conduct searches within detention centres if there is suspected illegal activity taking place, and as law enforcement officers they are the appropriate executors.
From a human rights perspective, this legislation sets a dangerous precedent that could be applied elsewhere in society in the future. Instead of cowing to a Peter Dutton scare campaign on migration, Labor should show some backbone and rethink this approach to managing migration detention centres.
Australia is better than this. We should be creating laws that ensure those in immigration detention are treated with dignity, are processed in a timely manner and do not suffer in dangerous environments.
The first step should be implementing all of the Human Rights Commission’s recommendations on reforming immigration detention. The second step should be a Royal Commission into our treatment of asylum seekers.
Earlier this year I introduced a bill to impose a strict 90-day limit on immigration detention and prohibit the detention of children. Rather than engaging in a race to the bottom on immigration, the government should be implementing positive reforms that end the cruelty and human rights violations that have characterised Australia’s detention regime since the 1990s.
ENDS
Other relevant posts
ABC Mornings Post-Budget Panel
ABC Radio Mornings, 26 March 2025
Kylea speaks with host Kathryn Robinson and Fowler's Dai Le MP about the 2025 Federal Budget, describing the government's headline-grabbing tax breaks as a "very tiny, very small green shoot" that indicates that Labor may be prepared to begin to consider larger scale tax reform. When asked about the upcoming election, Kylea reiterates her commitment to the community independent movement: "We need everyday Australians stepping up ... to bring their real-life, lived experience into Parliament House, because it's only when you have that experience that you understand the impact that some of these reforms will have."
Fairy Bread: A Bread & Butter Budget Sprinkled with Sugar Hits
Media Statement, 26 March 2025
The 2025 Federal budget is a classic bread and butter budget that focuses on the bare basics but lacks ambition. This time however, it’s more like fairy bread in that it’s sprinkled with a few sugar hits that offer temporary relief for some but no long term, lasting benefits.
The Coalition’s attack on the climate authority is a cynical attempt to put ideology over facts – it must be called out
The Guardian, 27 February 2025
On the Coalition's attack on the Climate Change Authority, Kylea writes: "As my grandmother used to say: we are all entitled to our own opinions. But we are not entitled to our own facts."
When does bipartisanship happen? When mutual self-interest is served
The Sydney Morning Herald, 19 February 2025
Economics editor Ross Gittins has described a bipartisan deal on electoral reform as “collusion”, saying the major parties have passed reforms that “advance their interests at the expense of the voters.” He says a minority government would allow independents to push for “braver policies in return for keeping the minority government in power. Not such a bad arrangement.”
‘Swimming in debt’: Sydney’s $14 billion student loan burden
The Sydney Morning Herald, 16 February 2025
New data shows that North Sydney is region with the 4th highest number of students with HELP debt (44,030).
The 12 teal battlegrounds to watch out for this election
Australian Financial Review, 26 February 2025
After the wave of independents that swept the 2022 election, here are the 35 community-backed independents to watch out for as we head towards the polls.
Every Friday
Kylea's newsletter hits the inboxes of people right across our electorate of North Sydney. Stay up to date with Kylea's plans and progress as she tells us about her week speaking with people in our community. We'll also highlight the latest community events and initiatives to get involved with.